CISO Desk Reference Guide Volume 2

by Bill Bonney, Gary Hayslip, Matt Stamper
CISO Desk Reference Guide Volume 2 cover

On this page

Highlights

For Chapter 10, we began our discussion by asking these four questions:   How do CISOs develop their hiring priorities to support the organization and their cybersecurity program effectively? What hard and soft skills does the CISO believe their cybersecurity program requires? How can I construct a training program that will keep my team’s knowledge, skills, and techniques current? What metrics can I use to measure the effectiveness of my cybersecurity team’s capabilities to provide security services and reduce risk to the organization?
It is essential to recognize that the CISO, and the entire Information Security team, are continually recruiting. Every opportunity to interact with your community is an opportunity to assess and impress the people that can help you succeed.
You should identify formal and informal networking activities offered by your community to make sure you have an appropriate presence at these events. Remember to include your team as recruiting is often most effective at the peer level. Also, include a thorough review of social media profiles and activities.
Given the depth and breadth of knowledge that a cybersecurity team must possess, it is impossible to acquire and maintain a staff that can do everything. Various third parties have virtual monopolies on specific expertise.
You should conduct a gap analysis of the cybersecurity capabilities your organization requires versus what your team can realistically provide. With this in hand, create a plan of action to fill the gaps through hiring, training, and outsourcing to third-party providers.
Cybersecurity is simultaneously a broad, very technical and relatively new field. As the CISO, you need to ensure that the roles you define are well matched to your objectives and to the technology your organization is using.
You should work with your human resources partner to calibrate job roles, banding, salary and title and validate that you have appropriately reflected this in any posted job openings.
Given the extreme business reliance on technology in the digital era, you as the CISO need to be aware of the unique environmental conditions that drive the concentration of the talent you will need to address your business risk, as well as the factors that create unique challenges and opportunities in attracting that talent.
You should conduct a review of the environmental factors that affect your industry, your organization and the specific talent you need to attract, and then develop a strategy to highlight your opportunities and overcome your challenges.
Highly-skilled individuals are motivated more by a sense of purpose and opportunity to grow than they are by salary and traditional benefits. As the CISO, you need to make sure that your team is effective in delivering on its objectives and that your people continue to grow and develop.
You should align the metrics you routinely track to your organization’s goals and to the capability to deliver on those goals so that growth and development of personnel are a standard aspect of your continual improvement effort.
For Chapter 11, we began our discussion by asking these four questions:   What are the “lessons learned” from industry data breaches that can be used to reduce our organization’s risk exposure to these adverse events? How successful is training our staff in actually preventing breaches versus having the right software and hardware in place? Does our organization have a culture of cybersecurity awareness and do we have a program to educate our staff? What is our Incident Response Plan and how do we train staff, stakeholders and partners on how to use this plan?
You need to align your cyber awareness education program needs with the organization’s goals for the program to be effective. While a great many cyber-related regulations mandate cyber awareness training, your job as the CISO is to try to help the organization avoid the trap of administering the program as just another compliance activity.
You should evaluate and adjust your existing cyber awareness education program to ensure that the messaging and any calls to action are visibly linked to organizational objectives, so your workforce sees the immediate relevance of the training.
We are at a point in the ongoing struggle against cybercrime where every organization must recognize the threat and take sustained action to ensure its survival.
You should work with your peers and senior leadership to create a unified plan with consistent support across the entire organization. Coordinate the efforts and include messaging, materials, and well-defined roles and responsibilities in the ecosystem. Communicate messaging and roles broadly, and continually reinforce them.
A unified plan will only be effective if each senior leader recognizes the value and is fully engaged in solving cyber awareness problems that represent specific threats to their line of business.
You should work with your peers and senior leadership to make sure they are informed about cybersecurity in the context of their organization. The goal of their engagement is an open dialog on cyber risk and cyber resilience that aligns the various elements of the cyber awareness education program to the needs of the organization.
Continual learning and continual improvement are essential elements of success. Best practices such as formalizing a review of lessons learned from every breach can also play a vital role in your cyber awareness program.
You should establish a formal process to absorb lessons learned from each breach and ensure that the resulting improvements include making appropriate updates to your cyber awareness program and communicating them.
We’ve discussed metrics at length in both volumes of the CISO Desk Reference Guide. Given that your cyber awareness education program is vital to achieve cyber resilience, some metrics you collect will directly measure the effectiveness of your cyber awareness program (such as familiarity with messaging) or indirectly measure its effectiveness (such as click-through rates on phishing campaigns).
You should review the metrics you track and identify the metrics that indirectly measure your program, typically identified as behaviors that you wish to limit or encourage within your workforce. These might include clicking on links and changing passwords. You should also make sure you have appropriate metrics that directly track the effectiveness of your program, such as familiarity with messaging and cost of recovery from incidents directly related to user activity, such as virus infections via click-through.
As a CISO, it is essential to understand the idea of “reasonable care” and why it is a minimum strategic standard for the business. This concept is based on several core principles:
The organization, or the CISO acting on its behalf, shall be considered to have complied with reasonable security practices and procedures if an industry standard framework was used to implement the procedures
For Chapter 12, we began our discussion by asking these three questions: As a CISO, what frameworks, security controls, or processes would you recommend to continuously monitor your organization to prevent or mitigate a data breach? What framework and/or processes should a CISO use to remediate vulnerabilities and search for malware in their organization’s application portfolio? Your organization experiences numerous unauthorized attempts to breach its enterprise networks. What metrics are important to your enterprise cybersecurity program to enable it to see these attempts? Given the overwhelming volume of data and the exponentially expanding number of devices and breadth of your network, we can’t emphasize enough how important it is to think strategically about what you need to monitor and how you’ll build an infrastructure to do so.
It is essential that you have sensors on every critical part of your network. When you inherit a monitoring program, it’s safe to assume that time pressures, budget pressures, or less-than-ideal change management have left part of your network unwatched. These failures create dark zones that could leave your infrastructure exposed.
You should conduct a thorough review of your assets and the activity and log data you are collecting to make sure all…
Due to the large volume of data collected, it is often impossible to look at all of it, and it’s rare to have the spare time needed to conduct random threat hunting. While being able to reconstruct what happened after a breach can help you tighten your defenses, looking at real-time indicators of compromise is…
You should continually assess your most critical business processes and make sure that you have event monitoring in place to detect indicators of compromise for potential breaches with the…
It is easy to become so focused on day-to-day operations that we fail to make time to look at the bigger picture with as much rigor as we do to metrics such as mean time to detection and processes like incident response. But having a good understanding of the entity-level health of your security program can…
You should review your security program governance processes and the checkpoints that you have in place to validate that these processes are operating both at the necessary level to ensure regulatory compliance and adherence to contract obligations,…
All breaches are not created equal. While we’d like to ensure perfect protection for all business assets, the reality is we need to make hard choices every day…
You should evaluate your business processes along with your scanning and monitoring to verify that you are focusing your attention on the assets that are vital…
As the hard, defensible network perimeter has become soft and permeable, your applications are now accessible from virtually every corner of the world by your workforce and your customers…
You should threat model your applications and add monitoring to detect the attempted exploitation of your…
For Chapter 13, we began our discussion by asking these three questions: What is threat intelligence, and what types of external threat intelligence sources should the CISO use to augment their cybersecurity suite? What are the business scenarios for incorporating threat intelligence services into an enterprise cybersecurity program? Which Open Source Threat Intelligence (OSINT) resources should a CISO consider for enhancing their threat vulnerability management program?
In addition to the cross over between threats that operate in the physical and digital worlds, the law enforcement community has enormous experience in gathering threat intelligence.
You should uncover all of the touchpoints between your organization and both the law enforcement and regulatory communities. Ensure that you have defined an appropriate two-way information flow in each case and develop a process to regularly utilize that information flow.
The informal human network that you have been building serves as an invaluable source of threat intelligence, from pooled and shared feeds to side-channel discussion to a short list of who to call and who might warn you of impending threat.
You should review how the people in your human network prefer to interact and look for opportunities to join or organize your colleagues. Take advantage of existing communities or form your own if needed.
Context is everything. All the threat intelligence available to you won’t do you any good unless you know how it applies to your organization, in your industry, and in your region.
You should review each of the six keys to threat intelligence and make sure you have a complete understanding of how each affects you. Revisit this annually or as major changes occur within your business or when major seminal breaches occur.
You can easily be overwhelmed with threat intelligence data. The data you use has to be data you trust because you’re going to make daily priority decisions based on that data.
You should conduct an assessment of the threat intelligence data you are receiving by validating which feeds are accurate and timely and which are not. Eliminate the untimely and inaccurate data feeds. This step alone can dramatically improve the fidelity of your threat intelligence program.
After you have validated your data feeds and uncluttered your life by eliminating untimely, inaccurate, and redundant sources, it’s time to remediate the gaps that remain.
You should review the Open Source Threat Intel (OSINT) sources and match the structure and content to your gaps. This will allow you to quickly and inexpensively create a complete program to fit your needs.
For Chapter 14, we began our discussion by asking these questions: What is a Business Continuity Plan (BCP) and what are the steps to create one? What critical components should a Disaster Recovery Plan (DRP) include to be effective? What value does the CISO’s security program receive from the organization’s Business Continuity Plan and its associated Disaster Recovery Plan?
We have suggested various actions that are focused on learning about your environment at a deep level. We’ve asked you to complete a business impact analysis (BIA), learn about your critical business processes, take inventory of your critical assets, and assess your talent. All of this is in support of becoming a more resilient organization.
You should aggregate your BIA and your process, asset and talent inventories into a repository and add recovery prioritization and sequencing information that would be used in recovery operations.
We have evolved from a time when hardware failures, coding errors and natural disasters were the only drivers of business continuity and disaster recovery plans. The means to disrupt, damage and profit remotely have added an important dimension to recovery planning.
You should add a strategy for protecting your backups and your recovery plans from a cyberattack. This strategy will help ensure both resilience for your operations and make your organization less susceptible to the ransomware family of attacks.
Risk is the business of the CISO. Risk informs how the CISO directs the security resources of the organization and risk informs how the organization prepares for adverse events to ensure resilience across the lines of business.
You should update and integrate the risk assessments you have done as part of your Chapter 4 third-party risk assessment and your Chapter 7 risk management actions into your process and asset recovery repository.
The adage is that the devil is in the details. This adage has never been truer than when you are preparing the detailed runbooks needed to recover processes and systems after a significant disruption. You are often executing procedures rarely if ever run in combination and by people who never witnessed the small tweaks needed to launch successfully.
You should add recovery strategies and detailed step-by-step recovery instructions for processes and assets in your recovery repository.
Business processes connect people to customers, tools, and outcomes and form the backbone of value delivery. Expertise matters and having the right people engaged in critical decision-making saves valuable time and can help avoid severe errors.
You should establish and then record in your recovery repository the owners and subject matter experts for all the processes and assets so that you can reach the right people when needed to recover your critical business processes.
Communicating effectively during an incident is also critical to maintaining the confidence of the organization’s many stakeholders, and preparation is key to success here as well.
While responding to incidents is not the only thing we do in the cybersecurity discipline, it is critically important, and our management judges us based on how well we do it because it is so visible.
The ability to quickly and correctly recover from cyber incidents has direct implications for the organization’s resilience and may directly impact the balance sheet.
In Chapter 15, we began our discussion by asking these questions: Some of the questions the authors used to frame their thoughts for this chapter include: What is the business value of an Incident Response Program (IRP)? What are the processes to create an IRP? What are some methods to measures the effectiveness of an organization’s IRP and why is it important to the CISO?
It is difficult to predict how many challenges will be presented to you when a live incident is underway. What you do know is that time will be a precious commodity and resources will be severely limited. Key decision makers will be engaged on multiple fronts. Keeping your various stakeholders informed should be a high priority because not adding to the problem will be a critical concern.
You should create a list of the potential communication events that might arise during a cyber incident. These might include disruptions to product deliveries, closure of facilities, and estimated time of service restoration. Build a template for each potential event and obtain pre-approval so that in a crisis, fundamental messaging is ready for use.
Knowing who to call, who to escalate to and who needs to be informed about incidents impacting and efforts to recover each asset is critical. This knowledge helps you make timely decisions and…
You should add to your template repository the primary owner and escalation point, along with escalation criteria, for each message template. Key people on this list are the business owners who manage the customer, supplier, employee, and law enforcement…
The combination of integrating OT and IT along with increased regulatory and law enforcement activity and the added awareness of users of their own peril have added several new…
You should document and communicate the intersection between OT and IT in your environment and conduct tabletop exercises to simulate the decision-making challenges across the three axes of service delivery, law-enforcement, and data protection. Repeat these drills often enough that making the hard calls between the…
We’ve been discussing runbooks in various contexts, but there is perhaps no area where a detailed and verified runbook is more important than incident response. Much like pre-approved communication templates, having a detailed set of procedures that comprise your incident…
You should build an action plan based on the eleven steps outlined to develop an incident response program. The plan should have the specific objective of identifying and closing the gaps…
Most metrics the CISO tracks are valuable beyond the context of just the information security program, and this is particularly true for metrics about the incident response program. Routinely reporting on cyber hygiene, incident response and…
You should verify that your metrics program captures sufficient data points to allow you to measure your incident response program effectively. Use the metrics listed in…
In Chapter 16 we began our discussion by asking these questions: What steps should an organization take to prepare for a data breach? During a data breach, what operations should the CISO be aware of and possibly manage as a member of the organization’s business continuity effort and leader of the incident response team? What steps should be followed to resume normal operations and resume data breach management efforts?
Don’t make the problem worse than it is. When systems are partially disrupted, the application-level controls for access to data are easily to circumvent by mistake. This can escalate a routine service interruption into a privacy violation that triggers a breach notification.
You should catalog data handling procedures for recovery activities that adhere to regulatory and contractual restrictions.
While many large organizations have experienced dozens to hundreds of incidents that have forced them to develop mature incident response programs, smaller organizations, and inexperienced teams do not have that collective muscle memory upon which to rely.
You should develop a management response checklist to drive the initial role assignments for the executive team, including at least you and the CIO and your incident manager. The initial response steps should seek to triage the damage and bring calm to the response teams.
Helmuth von Moltke the Elder famously said: “No battle plan survives contact with the enemy.” Moltke was coming to understand that with modern weapons and larger, better equipped armies, resilience was far more important than drilling to achieve perfect battle formation. Resilience, in his mind, was achieved through what-if exercises that exposed his leaders to as many realistic scenarios as possible, so they could adapt to changing conditions.
You should build a tabletop exercise using similar circumstances to those outlined by Matt for the hospital to allow your management team to simulate a breach response and recovery, so you can begin to develop your muscle memory.
During an incident is the wrong time to reach out to establish a relationship with law enforcement, your regulators, your vendors, or anyone upon whom you will rely in a crisis.
You should perform a gap analysis of your state of data breach readiness as defined by the Department of Justice’s eight steps a company can take to prepare and build action plans to close the gaps.
Each network is different. Each attack, while often of common origin, mutates as obstacles are encountered and countermeasures are deployed. While difficult to do in the moment, learning to take notes about how the attack is unfolding and the measures you are taking is invaluable as input for training and process improvement.
You should build a narrative that describes the anatomy of each breach you experience, giving specific attention to the recovery efforts and what went wrong during recovery so that subsequent recovery efforts can evolve. Repeat this process for each subsequent security incident that involves a service disruption and measure the performance of recovery efforts over time.
In Chapter 17, we began our discussion by asking these three questions: What is digital forensics and what value does it bring to the business? What resources are required to develop a digital forensics lab and should the CISO build one? What roles and resources are needed to field a digital forensics team?
The chain of custody for evidence must be established immediately. This is not something that can be done retroactively. Consequently, you need to know ahead of time the circumstances under which you must preserve evidence, the exact items to collect, and the appropriate handling procedures.
You should work with your legal team to establish criteria for sequestering assets and build a checklist of all the items to collect when the criteria have been met.
Learning from failure is essential as the likelihood of being attacked again is near 100%. Asking ourselves what we could have done differently and what we experienced that we didn’t expect are invaluable disciplines.
You should create your own template for conducting post-mortem reviews to answer the questions laid out in this section, incorporating additions and changes based on your internal review and your repetition of the post-mortem review process.
Our partners in law enforcement have lots of experience in collecting and preserving evidence. In addition, judges and prosecutors routinely make them aware of the requirements for what to collect and how to protect what has been gathered.
You should, along with your legal counsel, meet with appropriate law-enforcement departments and update your list from action #1 to include items requested by law enforcement and cleared by your legal group.
Though not necessarily in support of forensic activity, you will likely be asked to sequester evidence for civil litigation, regulatory enforcement, or internal investigation of potential employee misconduct.
You should review your tools for evidence collection and make sure adequate e-discovery capabilities are included.
Though we know some level of capability will be required for most organizations, due to the equipment and expertise required, forensics can be one of the most expensive services to provide. Using a third-party service provider to augment your capabilities will usually be necessaryYou
should work with one or more third-party forensics companies to build a roadmap for creating your organization’s forensic capability using the appropriate combination of in-house and outsourced services.
In Chapter 18, we began our discussion by asking these three questions: What components should the CISO use in developing their cybersecurity strategic plan? How should the CISO align their strategic plan to the organization’s business objectives? What steps can the CISO use to leverage the cybersecurity strategic plan for future growth?

94 highlights, exported from my Kindle via Readwise.

Subscribe to Ishan Girdhar newsletter and stay updated.

Don't miss anything. Get all the latest posts delivered straight to your inbox. It's free!
Great! Check your inbox and click the link to confirm your subscription.
Error! Please enter a valid email address!