The Great CEO Within

by Matt Mochary, Alex MacCaw, and Misha Talavera
The Great CEO Within cover

On this page

Highlights

There are many reasons to create a company, but only one good one: to deeply understand real customers (living humans!) and their problem, and then solve that problem.
Your partner’s purpose is not to be value-add forever. As your company grows, you will likely find people with far greater skills whom you will hire. That’s okay. Your co-founder’s purpose is to help you achieve success in your march to product-market fit. Once you get there and begin the blitzscaling process, be pleased if they continue to add value beyond that point.
While it is critical to have a partner to share the emotional burden of starting a company, each additional team member (co-founder, partner, or employee) adds additional complexity in geometric fashion. Each new member must somehow grok the priorities, vision, and actions of the other team members in order to place their efforts in the same direction. The more team members you have, the geometrically harder it is to share what is currently going on with everyone, as well as have everyone be emotionally bought into the decisions being made. Do not underestimate this cost. It is much larger than most founders think.
Y Combinator has another strong belief: founding teams should never grow beyond six until there is true product-market fit. Product-market fit (PMF) is the milestone of having created a product that customers are finding so much value in that they are willing to both buy it (after their test phase) and recommend it. Metrics that show whether PMF has been achieved include revenue, renewal rates, and Net Promoter Score.
The first goal of the company should be to achieve real PMF, not vanity metrics that fool people inside and outside the company that PMF has been achieved. For a B2B company, know that enterprise customers have budgets just for testing new technology and will buy your product to do just that. This does not mean that you have achieved PMF. For these types of customers, only long-term contracts are an indication that they actually value your product and want to use it. There is no magic metric, but for a B2B company, it’s hard to imagine PMF at anything less than $1 million in annual recurring revenue.
There is no magic metric, but for a B2B company, it’s hard to imagine PMF at anything less than $1 million in annual recurring revenue.
Why not grow beyond six team members before reaching PMF? Three main reasons: morale, communication and organization, and speed.
By contrast, with six or fewer people, the environment feels like a team in battle. Chaos is expected. So when chaos is actually encountered, the team meets it with glee. People who join small teams crave the challenge of new things. They want things to be hard.
Startups don’t usually fail because they grow too late. They usually fail because they grow too early (i.e., before they have achieved product-market fit).
Great companies are made up of great individual performers who work well together as a team. As CEO, you are both the architect of the culture and the central hub in the wheel of information flow that enables the team to function effectively. Your example inspires your team, and your efficiency determines the efficiency of the team. Therefore, the first thing to optimize is yourself.
Everyone needs an organizational system to track goals, priorities, and tasks. The majority of successful CEOs that I know use the system outlined in the book Getting Things Done: The Art of Stress-Free Productivity by David Allen. While the book is dense, it is definitely worth reading in its entirety.
Think of your combined inboxes as a single triage room at a hospital. Some cases that come in are urgent, others not so much. It is critical to notice the urgent cases immediately and get them in to see a doctor now. To do so, you must keep the triage room clear. If you use the triage room also as a waiting room, then a new patient can enter the room, sit down in a chair, and bleed out from his stab wound before you even realize he is there. For this reason, every well-functioning hospital separates its triage room from its waiting room and keeps the triage room absolutely clear. To be efficient, you must do the same with your inbox. This means addressing all the urgent cases right away and maintaining Inbox Zero every day.
If it takes more than two minutes, write down a next action for it (according to the steps in chapter 3), and then place the email in its correct location (Next Actions, Waiting For, Someday/Maybe, or Reference). The best way that I have found to do this when using Gmail is to implement the method described in Andreas Klinger’s blog post “Don’t Drown in Email! How to Use Gmail More Efficiently.” Andreas explains how to use Gmail’s Multiple Inbox feature to create an inbox for Next Actions, Waiting For, Someday/Maybe, and Reference. You can set the system up in fifteen minutes.
The top goal framework will help you fix this. Greg McKeown, who wrote a phenomenal book on productivity called Essentialism: The Disciplined Pursuit of Less, boils this down to one key concept: Schedule two hours each day (i.e., put an event in your calendar) to work on your top goal only. And do this every single workday. Period.
Schedule two hours each day (i.e., put an event in your calendar) to work on your top goal only. And do this every single workday. Period.
In addition to being on time, you must also be present. Being present means that you are composed, prepared, and focused on the subject matter. It can take a few minutes to “get present”—prepare for the meeting, research the topic and the attendees, go to the bathroom between back-to-back meetings, get a drink or snack, and so on. Therefore, I recommend that you plan to arrive to an outside meeting fifteen minutes before it is scheduled to begin. For a meeting in your office, wrap up your current project or previous meeting five to ten minutes before the scheduled time for the next meeting.
Whenever you find yourself saying something for a second time (to a second audience or in a second situation), it is highly likely that you will end up saying it again and again in the future. To vastly improve the quality of the communication and reduce the amount of time that you spend communicating the information, write it down.
So how do we take advantage of this knowledge to generate a good feeling in ourselves? We ask the right question: “What is good about this situation?” “What is good about this team member?” “What is good about my company?” “What is good about my life?” Or we simply fill in the overarching statement “I am grateful for ________.” Be as specific as possible: names of people, actions they did, and so on.
I recommend making this a daily practice. I do it first thing every morning. To remember to do it, create a trigger for yourself. A trigger is something that you will see at the time that you want to do the action. Using a trigger allows you to easily create a habit. The easiest trigger, in this case, is a piece of paper with the word gratitude printed on it and taped to your night table, the wall by your bed, or the mirror in your bathroom. When you see it each morning, you say the phrase “I am grateful for ________” five times with a different ending each time. (You don’t have to say it out loud; you can say it silently to yourself.) The key is to be as specific as possible when you declare what you are grateful for.
a First Round Review article titled “How to Become Insanely Well-Connected,” Chris Fralic of First Round Capital says that he reserves one hour each week for follow-ups and outreach, most of which include appreciations. I recommend that you do the same.
Tasks in the Zone of Excellence are the things that you are excellent at (i.e., better than others) but don’t love doing. This is the danger zone. Many people will want you to keep doing these things (because they gain significant value from you doing them), but this is the area that you should also look to move away from. This is the hard one!
Finally, tasks in the Zone of Genius are the things that you are uniquely good at in the world and that you love to do (so much so that time and space seem to disappear when you do them). This is where you can add most value to the world and yourself. This is where you should be driving toward spending most, if not all, of your time.
If your company truly succeeds, you will likely find yourself equity rich but still cash poor. It is important to create liquidity and diversify out of your company’s stock. The general rule of thumb is that you should have no more than 25 percent of your net worth in “alternative assets” (illiquid assets). Because your company’s equity is likely the majority of your net worth, your net worth is likely more than 95 percent alternative assets. It will be close to impossible to sell 75 percent of your stake in your company. Instead, know that there are two absolute numbers that are significant: $10 million and $100 million.
So start by placing your liquid assets in a brokerage firm. Then invest all the cash into US Treasuries while you decide on your investment strategy.
David F. Swensen is the chief investment officer for the Yale University Endowment. He is considered the grandfather of portfolio management. He wrote a book specifically for the individual investor titled Unconventional Success: A Fundamental Approach to Personal Investment. I consider it the bible for individual asset management. In it, he convincingly describes how professional money managers’ ability to create alpha is exceedingly rare, and what few of these managers there are, you likely will never meet them, as they will choose to raise capital only from the most desirable LPs (e.g., Yale University).
Jeff Bezos, founder and CEO of Amazon, requires that anyone who wants to bring up an issue or proposal must write up the item fully before the decision meeting (with someone else writing up a counterproposal if necessary). The meeting is then spent reading the write-ups. Once the decision-making team has read them all, a decision is made. If consensus is not reached, the pre-appointed decision maker makes the call. If there are still open questions, then the decision maker assigns one or more people to research and, of course, write the needed follow-up. At the end of the next meeting, the decision is made.
Each time there is a decision to be made, rate it as irreversible or reversible. If it’s reversible, allow one of your reports to be the D (the decision maker in the RAPID process). The decision will be made faster, your report will get the chance to exercise their decision-making muscle, and you will have the chance to gain confidence in your reports’ ability to make decisions well.
There must be consequences for breaking agreements. Implementing these consequences is a two-part process. The first time someone doesn’t meet an agreement, you point it out to them immediately. If they apologize, you respond that apologies are not needed, and all that is required is that they only make agreements that they can commit to and that they meet all the agreements they make, whether by adherence or by prompt communication that they need to alter the agreement.
The five primary emotions are anger, fear, sadness, joy, and excitement. Knowing how to express them all of the way through to completion helps us develop emotional intelligence. Each primary emotion has a unique energy pattern and set of sensations in and on the body. Every feeling we experience invites us in a specific way to grow in awareness and knowing. Repressing, denying, or recycling emotions creates physical, psychological, and relationship problems.
Interpersonal conflict arises often. And almost always it is due to people (a) not fully sharing their feelings and thoughts and (b) not feeling heard. There is a laughably simple method for solving this issue. Stephen Covey shared the technique in The 7 Habits of Highly Effective People: Powerful Lessons in Personal Change. Marshall B. Rosenberg codified it in Nonviolent Communication: A Language of Life. And Chris Voss showed its effectiveness in his excellent Never Split the Difference: Negotiating as If Your Life Depended on It. I recommend reading all three of these books to get fully immersed in their techniques, but here is the thousand-foot view.
When people feel distrust or dislike for each other, it is usually because they don’t feel heard. For me to respect you, I don’t need for you to agree with me. But I do need for you to hear what I have to say. When I tell you my perspective (which I, of course, believe to be right) and you aren’t immediately convinced, then I assume that you didn’t really hear or understand what I said. If you start sharing your perspective, I will be uncompelled and unwilling to truly listen, because you haven’t been willing to consider mine. And the cycle spirals downward to distrust and dislike.
There is a simple fix. I only need to prove to you that I have “heard” you. And to do that, I only need to repeat back what you’ve said in summary form (by saying, “I think I heard you say…”) until you say, “That’s right!” Then you will feel heard. You will now be open to hearing what I have to say.
Your sales department will already have a customer-centric mind-set, but it is important for them not to prioritize every customer request. Customers know exactly what pain they are feeling, and they know that they want relief. But they don’t know how feasible each solution is. You do. After identifying all customer pain points, for each, rate the amount of pain that the customer feels and the degree of difficulty for you to solve it. Then work first on the issues with the highest customer pain that are the easiest for you to solve.
Culture is the unspoken set of rules that people in a group follow when interacting with one another. You act differently when you’re in a bar than when you’re at a family dinner. That’s because the rules that run the interactions between the different nodes in the networks have changed. Culture is the name for those rules.
Just as an efficient city requires comprehensive and trustworthy systems to move its traffic, goods, and by-products, your company requires reliable systems to maintain its data and communications flow. Without a solid infrastructure, your brilliant and talented team members won’t be able to function to their full potential. The key components to a solid company infrastructure are a company folder system and wiki, goal-tracking tools, areas of responsibility, no single point of failure, and key performance indicators. Let’s break each of those down.
Here’s an easy way to do this: Whenever you find yourself doing something twice, write down exactly what it is that you did. If you’ve done something twice, you’re likely to need to do it again, and someone else may need to do it too. When it’s documented, there are clear instructions to follow, which allow for consistency across employees and client situations. Place these written processes in the company wiki.
Task-tracking systems are excellent at transforming issues to next actions and tracking progress from meeting to meeting. They’re a key part of forming impeccable agreements (chapter 13) between people. Whenever two people form an agreement, it should be recorded in the task-tracking system and have an owner, a comprehensive description, and a due date.
Once you have achieved product-market fit, that is the right time to blitzscale and win the race to market share. You’re going to need to diversify your skills and grow your team. To do this, you will need to create massive awareness (marketing), walk many customers through the sales process (sales), hold those customers’ hands as they set up and use your product or service (customer success), harden your infrastructure to withstand many users at once (DevOps), get rid of technical debt and add all the features promised in your roadmap (engineering), update the product roadmap to meet the most urgent needs of your customers (product), and all the nontechnical operations (people [recruiting, training, and HR], finance, legal, office). All of this requires hiring talented and experienced people to fulfill those functions. First raise the money needed to hire this team, and then begin hiring.
A product manager is someone who both has the social skills to sit with customers and is (or can learn to be) technical enough to know what can and cannot be done technically. Whether the product manager has to have a background as an engineer is a hot point of contention. Some say that there is no other way; others say that it doesn’t really matter. From my experience, technical knowledge is very helpful; however, it is not a deal breaker, especially if the product manager has a good relationship with the technical lead and together they can solve problems honestly and efficiently.
Sit with real-life potential and actual customers and deeply get to know the customer’s life and problems. Because the product manager is technical, they know what features are possible (and how hard or easy they are to create) and can then list a set of features that will solve a customer’s deepest problems. The product manager then assigns an initial order to the features in the list according to the value they bring to the customer and the difficulty for the engineering team to create them.
This accountability, coaching, and transparency needs to happen in both directions (from CEO to the company, and from the company to the CEO) and at every level (company, department, team, and individual). This is best achieved through a series of weekly meetings. We’ll cover them in more detail in the next chapter, but I want to emphasize here that each manager should plan to devote a full day each week to internal meetings. The overhead—20 percent of the standard workweek—can feel tremendous to a startup CEO who is accustomed to the organic information flow of a small group working together in the same room. But without this one-day-per-week investment, a larger team will never fully know what to do, nor will the CEO get the needed feedback on their performance or the company’s performance.
Start the meeting day with the weekly one-on-one meetings. The weekly leadership team meeting will be the longest (up to three hours in the beginning, until the team learns the habit of writing down all input before the meeting, and then it can get down to thirty minutes). The CEO open office hour, all-hands meeting, and company-wide social event will consume the remainder of the day. The one-day limit for all internal meetings directly relates to how many team members a single manager can effectively oversee. If one of your managers can’t fit all the necessary meetings into a single day, they have too many people reporting directly to them and you need to reorganize, or they need to run more efficient meetings.
I recommend that all team members read the same book to get on the same page about what the purpose and structure of these meetings will be. If you manage managers, then that book should be the best one: Andy Grove’s High Output Management. This book is the gold standard for how to effectively manage a team. But it is not short. If you manage individual contributors who are unlikely to read a long book, then instead ask the team to read The One Minute Manager by Kenneth Blanchard and Spencer Johnson. It’s a very short read (thirty minutes), and it contains simple, effective advice. Assigning it uniformly will make sure your whole team has a common basis for proceeding.
At the end of every quarter, gather the leadership team together and collaborate on the coming quarter’s OKRs during the quarterly off-site meeting. I’ve found the process that gets the best results and most buy-in is to use structured brainstorming: Ask every member of your leadership team to separately write up what they think the global OKRs of the company should be. Then simply combine everyone’s ideas into one document. You will see common themes and have a healthy debate about the company’s priorities.
If, on the other hand, you use a one-way communication method (email, text, or voicemail), then the recipient can easily become defensive and angry without you realizing it. And because you don’t notice the anger, you won’t be able to address it. Unaddressed, that anger will soon turn into resentment toward you. Therefore, do not use a one-way communication method (email, text, or voicemail) to give feedback, unless it is 100 percent positive. There is one exception to this rule: if you already know the person to be open, curious, and desirous of critical feedback.
State how that trigger behavior makes you feel in terms of anger, sadness, and fear (feeling). This is perhaps the hardest part for many founders to do. Talking about your feelings might not be something you are used to, so it might be challenging at first. However, doing so is crucial for the other person to truly understand where you are coming from and to take your feedback to heart.
When you want to be introduced to an investor, first find three to five people in your network who know that person. Then ask those three to five people each to send an email to the target investor, letting the target investor know how great they think you are and highly recommending meeting you. After receiving several such emails, the investor will proactively reach out to you. The investor has received recommendations before, but never three or more for the same person. The investor concludes that you and your company must be truly great and is already inclined to invest in you before even meeting you.
Mark Zuckerberg retains total control of Facebook even though he owns only a minority of its shares. Why? Because the shares he owns come with extra votes. Now that this structure has been accepted by investors, there is little reason not to set it up in your own company. And the easiest time to do this is prior to having equity investors. Ask your lawyers to set up “FF shares with ten times or twenty times voting rights” prior to investors being on the cap table (SAFEs are fine).
The key is efficiency. And to be efficient, you must spend as little time as possible with the candidates you don’t hire (quick evaluation) and as much time as possible with the candidates you want to and do hire (building a relationship and onboarding/training). Remember that each minute you spend with a candidate you don’t hire is a minute that you aren’t spending with the candidate you want to hire.
Referrals from your personal and professional networks are by far the most effective. Use this process for sourcing such referrals: Create a list of the ten most talented people you know. Commit to speaking to at least one of them each week for the next ten weeks, asking them, “Who are the three most talented people you know?” Continue to build your list and continue to talk with at least one person per week. Document everything in your company’s applicant tracking system (ATS).
If you can’t definitively say, “This is an A player,” then hit the gong. It is better to miss out on an A player than to waste many precious hours on a borderline case that turns out to be a B or C player. If you weed harshly, you will be able to spend more time with candidates who are known A players. End the call at the scheduled time (fifteen minutes, hopefully). Within twenty-four hours, inform the candidate that you appreciated their time but you will not be moving forward with them: “Thank you for taking the time to interview with us. We do not feel that our needs for this role match your strengths. That being said, we will be hiring for many more roles in the future, and we hope to be able to reach back out to you again.” While it may feel difficult to say no to people, it is disrespectful to let them linger. The vast majority of people prefer a quick no to a slow one, or worse yet, no response at all.
“Thank you for visiting us today. We are going to do a chronological interview and walk through each job you’ve had. For each job, I am going to ask you five core questions: What were you hired to do? What accomplishments are you most proud of? What were some low points during that job? Who were the people you worked with? Why did you leave that job?
Here is an example to show how the equity portion is calculated. Let’s say the position is a level 3 engineer who is paid $300,000 in total compensation at Google. The team member requires $120,000 in cash to live comfortably and wants to invest the remainder in startup equity. The amount of equity is calculated by taking the difference between market and cash ($300,000 – $120,000 = $180,000) and multiplying it by four years ($180,000 × 4 = $720,000). This amount is then divided by a factor somewhere between 1 and 2, which represents a very conservative estimate of the increase in value of the equity over four years. A factor of 1 represents no expected increase in value. A factor of 2 represents a two-times expected increase in value.
Most companies spend extraordinary resources of time, money, and equity to bring on a new team member, and then almost entirely drop the ball on quickly getting that team member onboarded and up to speed on how the company works so that they can begin making a full contribution. Don’t make this mistake! Give onboarding even more attention, time, and energy than you give to recruiting. After all, many of the people you are spending time with during recruiting will not become team members, whereas 100 percent of the people you spend time with during onboarding are already team members. Focus your energy there!
Write a checklist of all the information a team member would need to be fully effective. Write all this information down, and make a video of it. Share this checklist, the written and video information, and the ninety-day roadmap with each new team member as early as you can, even before they start.
Me (preface): Hi, Stacey! It’s good to have you on the phone. I’m looking forward to giving you a demo of NeoReach. Before I go ahead and do so, I would love to learn more about you and [company]. Can I ask you a couple of questions?
Generating leads and closing deals are distinct functions that must be split. Generating leads is a game of breadth: it requires emailing and talking to a lot of different leads to filter out the nonqualified ones as fast as possible. Closing deals is a game of depth: it requires building deep relationships and understanding with the qualified leads in order to close the deal.
Therefore, rather than go after the entire market at once, the key is to find a small segment of the market (i.e., a set of customers with similar pain points) that has a particularly difficult problem for whom your solution is indeed ten times better than the broad, nonspecific legacy solution. This is your low-hanging fruit. Concentrate all your efforts on this type of customer to maximize your chance of getting your first few customers. Once you do, you will then have a track record to share, be able to raise more money, and be able to hire more engineers to create more features and more salespeople to develop more relationships. Continue focusing on this first type of customer until you have secured many (if not most) of them as your customers. Then use your now-larger amount of resources to move to the next-lowest-hanging fruit.
Do the same. Study the marketplace. Segment it into different customer types. Determine which segment is the least satisfied with their current solution and for whom your solution is the best fit. Concentrate all your sales and engineering efforts toward this segment. Land a few of these customers. Continue to focus on this segment until you dominate it. Only then expand to other customer segments (or add other products).

59 highlights, exported from my Kindle via Readwise.

Subscribe to Ishan Girdhar newsletter and stay updated.

Don't miss anything. Get all the latest posts delivered straight to your inbox. It's free!
Great! Check your inbox and click the link to confirm your subscription.
Error! Please enter a valid email address!